Donald Clarke on Jimmy Kimmel’s Irish Trip
Jimmy Kimmel spoke politely about his recent visit to Ireland, praising the country’s decency, friendliness, and political maturity. However, Donald Clarke argues that Irish people are not inherently more polite or generous than citizens elsewhere, including those in the United States.
Personal Experience in New York City
About 4,000 years ago, Clarke traveled to New York City on a J1 visa and tried to find a job in a familiar field. He had to speak to a union representative for the relevant workforce, who was exceptionally helpful.
“You came all this way without a job? Let’s see what we can do.”
She offered advice, employment leads, and contact information for about half an hour. Before he left, she reassured him:
“Now, don’t let anyone tell you New Yorkers are rude.”
Clarke had not thought of New Yorkers as rude before this but noted that they could sometimes be brusque—just like people in any large city who don’t have time for small talk.
Reflection on Kimmel’s Praise
Clarke’s New York experience reminded him of Kimmel’s visit to Ireland. While Kimmel briefly mentioned Irish stereotypes like leprechauns, his overall message was one of respect for Ireland’s people and culture.
Key Points
- Irish politeness and generosity are not uniquely superior to those in other countries.
- People’s manners vary depending on context, whether in large cities or abroad.
- Kimmel’s visit highlighted positive views but did not reveal unique Irish traits.
Summary
Donald Clarke uses his New York experience to suggest that politeness is universal rather than unique to Ireland, challenging romanticized views of national character.